PLUS: Lord Speaker-watch
View in your browser
The Times and Sunday Times
Monday March 1 2021
Red Box
Esther Webber
By Esther Webber
Good morning,
Thanks for all the nice messages last week following the news that I will be leaving Red Box for pastures new and Patrick will be taking over full-time. Not to go all Theresa May-on-the-steps-of-Downing-Street about it, but it really has been an honour.

It's hard to think of another gig in Westminster which allows you to mingle with the stars (sorry, I mean MPs), track down exclusive stories, cover all the big political events and poke fun at the whole operation while you're at it - and with that in mind, I would heartily recommend applying to be the new Red Box reporter.

Trivia question: What do Conservatives Sir Paul Beresford and Baroness Gardner of Parkes have in common with Anas Sarwar, the new Scottish Labour Party leader? Answer at the bottom of today's email
Esther Webber
Red Box reporter
Twitter icon @estwebber
 
New this morning
  • Not what we wanted to hear: six people in Britain have tested positive for a Covid-19 mutation that is potentially more infectious and resistant to vaccines as a nationwide search is launched for one unidentified case. But it can't completely overshadow new evidence suggesting a single dose of the vaccine reduces the risk of hospital admission by more than 90 per cent.
  • Priti Patel, the home secretary, is planning a crackdown on people smugglers which would see them handed life sentences if caught. Almost like she needs to be seen to be doing something.
  • Support for Scottish independence dropped to 50 per cent for the first time since June in a poll at the weekend. It's being interpreted as evidence that the civil war within the SNP is taking its toll, but pollster Professor Sir John Curtice has written about why it may have more to do with Nicola Sturgeon's handling of the pandemic.
  • "A nest of singing birds" has immediately become my new favourite euphemism for "nothing to see here" after Allegra Stratton, the prime minister's press secretary, used it to deny a rift with Carrie Symonds. All the latest from the vipers' - sorry, birds' - nest here.
  • In the House: Education questions is at 2.30pm followed by motions on electricity supplier payments, automatic enrolment, and income tax exemption. At 4pm someone called David Cameron is giving evidence to the joint committee on national security strategy. Baroness Chapman of Darlington and Lord Etherton will be introduced at 1pm, and peers will discuss cadet forces, energy efficiency, US-UK relations, and reciprocal pension arrangements.
  • On Times Radio with Matt Chorley from 10am: Libberachi (Libby Purves and Rachel Sylvester) pick over the news (10.30am); Money talk with Paul Johnson (10.50am); The Big Thing: Unfair state or welfare state? Changing public attitudes towards benefits (11am); coffee break with Mariella Frostrup (11.35am); childhood in Yemen with Saleh Saeed (11.40am); Gimson’s PMs #9: Pitt The Elder (11.50am); Midday Update; If I Ruled The World: Metro bank boss Dan Frumkin (12.40pm); Quiz: Can You Get To Number 10? (12.50pm).
Playing the long game
We've had charming chancellors. We've had gruff ones. We've had posh ones and humble ones. But have we ever had a cool one?

Ken Clarke, with his louche approach to footwear and love of jazz, can lay a reasonable claim to that title. But Rishi Sunak, with his hoodies, his fancy gadgets and Nando's habit, is certainly giving him a run for his money.

Not content with his status as Instagram influencer par excellence, Sunak recently started his own email newsletter with a round-up of the week's news from No 11. The latest edition is topped with a picture of the famous red box, but Red Box will, for now, hold off suing for copyright infringement.

However, if he begins his statement on Wednesday by saying, "This is not normal," we may have to consider our options.

As Sunak himself notes, he had been in the job for less than a month when he delivered last year's budget, in what must go down in history as one of the most roasting baptisms of fire in politics.

At that point, three Britons in total had died from coronavirus, and while it was already clear he would have to help the country through a heavy economic shock, we had no idea how severe it would be or how long it would last.

If you had told me last March I would be in yet another lockdown one year later, well, I don't know what I would have done. Started tunnelling out through the basement and getting started on my way to New Zealand I guess.

When the chancellor announced a series of interventions, both in the budget and shortly afterwards as the country went into lockdown, his ratings went through the roof (as did the government's). On March 23, 2020, he hit +49 net favourability, the likes of which had not been seen since the days of Denis Healey.

Almost instantly, speculation started to build about when his star would begin to wane. Political logic dictated it: everyone likes the nice man giving out presents, but just you wait until he has to claw some of that largesse back.

But so far, that fall has not really happened - in part because we're not out of the woods yet, and we're still relying on him for additional money going into welfare and jobs.

It's true that his favourability zigzagged around the 50 per cent mark for the first half of last year and has now receded, but at 47 per cent it's still pretty darn respectable.

YouGov polling at the weekend found no huge demand for him to fill the financial hole until next year, while a new Opinium survey of business leaders shared with Red Box found:
  • A fifth (21 per cent) of businesses want to see the whole package of Covid measures wound down imminently, while over half (56 per cent) think that they should be wound down by the end of 2021.
  • Forty-two per cent of businesses think that the roadmap eases restrictions at the right pace, while the same proportion think they’re being eased too quickly. Only 9 per cent think they are being eased too slowly.
  • Two thirds (64 per cent) don’t think the economy will recover until after the end of the year, including three in ten (29 per cent) who think it will be 2023 or later until the economy has recovered.
As Opinium's Chris Curtis writes for us today: "At the beginning of this crisis he said that he would do whatever it takes; our polling shows that for businesses that means keeping support in place for just a little bit longer."

The good news for them is that Sunak has already signalled grants to businesses will be a priority and that he will extend the furlough scheme.

Overall the picture of the mood among businesses is one of forbearance, and a reasonably widespread acceptance that recovery and reopening will happen slowly. It suggests that the chancellor still has a reservoir of goodwill, or at least patience, to dip into when he makes his speech on Wednesday.

You'd think that was the last thing any of us were able to offer, as a nation which has had its collective fill of Zoom quizzes, live-streamed plays, dinner kits, walks in the park and watching the foliage change outside as intently as an HBO drama. After the pandemic it's my firm intention never to take pleasure in the small things again.

Why are we seemingly able to take the long view, even now, in a collective fug of boredom? It may be partly a function of the psychological rollercoaster ride we've all been treated to over the past year, in which we've learned there are no short cuts, and all we can do is plan for the worst and hope for the best.

The business leaders surveyed also sounded surprisingly relaxed about raising corporation taxes, with 38 per cent agreeing they are currently too low. Sunak is expected to announce that the rate of corporation tax will rise from 19 per cent to 25 per cent over this parliament.

While he will face resistance from some of his own colleagues, so far he's mainly making life difficult for the Labour Party, which is split on the idea and can't say where it would find extra money right now.

We've all become used to endless postponements and long waits as a result of the pandemic, and it seems as though the chancellor's political opponents will have to bide their time before he falls out of favour. Or, you know, come up with ideas of their own on taxes. Anything is possible.
Chart of the day
The majority of people now think that benefits are too low or about right, in a sharp reversal of attitudes towards the welfare state over the past decade.

In 2013, at the height of George Osborne’s austerity drive, 37 per cent of people thought benefits were too high, but that has more than halved to just 15 per cent, according to polling firm YouGov. At the same time the proportion of people who think payments are too low has jumped from 21 per cent to 35 per cent.

It comes as Rishi Sunak faces pressure to extend the £20 per week increase in the standard rate of universal credit.
  • Unfair or welfare state? Listen to Matt Chorley's debate on Times Radio from 10am.
Lord Speaker-watch
Now, she's probably not a household name, but she could be coming to a woolsack near you soon.

The race is on to succeed Lord Fowler, who is stepping down as Lord Speaker next month, and early favourite Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town has confirmed to Red Box she will be throwing her hat in the ring.

She said her priority was to get the two Houses working well together and "enable us to do the job better".

She promised to "keep the best of digital parliament" but added: "I hope vaccines can provide a route back. The House looks very strange and feels very strange when peers don't have the ability to come back on something a minister has said and keep that back-and-forth of deliberative debate going."

However, her candidacy has created some consternation in the Labour ranks. She is currently the deputy Labour leader in the Lords and Brexit spokeswoman, and as one party aide put it: "If she goes then there is no one impressive left on our front bench apart from Angela [Smith, Labour leader in the Lords]."

One peer wondered if it would lend new momentum to the idea of a mandatory retirement age. "There is a serious problem with securing youngsters to sit on the Labour front bench. It might actually precipitate a change in the way the Lords does business," he said.

Their lordships are apparently growing restless for a new cut-off point, with 75 widely discussed as the upper age limit. For it to be truly mandatory would require legislation, but peers could decide to adopt it by convention. Unfortunately for her, this would not give Lady Hayter (71) very long in the job.

Discussing her chances with another Labour contact, I asked if the party had a talent problem in the Lords. He replied: "Take out 'in the Lords'."
Red Box: Comment
Chris Curtis
Businesses fear chancellor’s generosity drying up too quick
Chris Curtis – YouGov

"It is clear that this budget is going to be critical for the chancellor, in terms of maintaining his popularity and ensuring the UK economy can bounce back from the pandemic. At the beginning of this crisis he said that he would do whatever it takes; our polling shows that for businesses that means keeping support in place for just a little bit longer."

Read the full article >
James Grundy and Dehenna Davison
Business rates reform essential to bright future for the high street
James Grundy and Dehenna Davison – Conservative MPs
Sunder Katwala
As Brexit divides fade, what happens next is in all our hands
Sunder Katwala – Director, British Future
Jonathan Simons and Ed Dorrell
Longer school days risk widening socio-economic divides
Jonathan Simons and Ed Dorrell – Public First
Raffaello Pantucci
Ignoring UK terrorists like Shamima Begum is not the answer
Raffaello Pantucci – RUSI
The cartoon
Today's cartoon in The Times is by Morten Morland.
Worth your time
"Libertarian bumper stickers are too neat to address the reality of balancing individual liberty with the public good in modern society. There are already many caveats on our freedoms in the name of collective safety," writes Clare Foges, in her column defending the concept of vaccine passports.

Libby Purves says we have to accept that Covid means the return of borders, but that it should make us appreciate travel all the more when we eventually get to do it. Ed Lucas discusses Russia's failure to confront its imperial past as a factor in the country's modern tendency to aggression.

At the start of another momentous week for Scotland, Magnus Linklater surveys the task ahead for Nicola Sturgeon: "She may emerge from Wednesday’s hearing with her position as first minister of Scotland intact. But something more profound will have been lost in the process."

For The i, Stephen Bush warns that Keir Starmer has not yet answered the question of how to repair his party's reputation on the economy. In the Telegraph, Nick Timothy finds little reason to hope for any kind of Beveridge "moment" . "Neither in the budget this week, nor in any other set-piece political speeches or moments, are we likely to see a grand vision or truly comprehensive plan to really change our society," he writes.

Bruce Springsteen and Barack Obama fanboys look away now: Lauren Michele Jackson puts her finger on something for the New Yorker, as she finds their joint podcast a bit too cuddly.

And by far the most entertaining thing I read over the weekend was Ed Cumming's piece for The Observer in which he holds up his hands and admits that as a Remoaner he's found Britain's runaway vaccine success hard to process.
A staggering 79 per cent of Red Box readers have received the vaccine, with another 13 per cent booked in for an appointment. Great stuff.
Have your say
On Saturday Patrick asked who should be the next first minister of Scotland.

David Martin: "Macron has all the qualifications. It would give him an opportunity to continue to disparage all things English, a nest to continue promoting the EU, and a safe haven from Marie Le Pen."

Stewart Ross: "Susan Calman would seem a perfect candidate to replace Saint Nicola, combining a legal background with onstage stand-up comedy - both essential attributes for surviving in the current bear pit of Scottish National Party politicking."

Roger Baker: "How about job-sharing between Billy Connolly and Susan Calman? The Scottish parliament could benefit from a break from bitter infighting. Billy and Susan are both popular in Scotland and in touch with the real world."

Michael Jobson: "Obviously it has to be whoever would provide the most material for southern armchair critics in taking the piss and nursing their own precious grievances (everyone seems to have ‘em)."

Dave Malcolm: "Donald Trump. The Scots seem to go for narcissistic leaders."

Kayla Tomlinson: "They shouldn't have one. Why duplicate the functions of Westminster at such an outrageous cost just to placate the Scottish Nationalist Party?"

P Fredrick was one of many people to suggest Ruth Davidson. "She seems capable, articulate and honest as politicians go and she wants to keep the Union."

Austin Fears: "There's only one worthy candidate and that's Ruth Davidson. If she doesn't get the job there could be a top job down in Westminster that she could do with one tied behind her back."

Neil Schofield: “Ruth Davidson who is by far the best politician in the UK.“

TODAY: What could Boris Johnson introduce as a team-building exercise for No 10? Email redbox@thetimes.co.uk and we'll use some of the best tomorrow.
 
Today's trivia answer
Trivia question: What do Conservatives Sir Paul Beresford and Baroness Gardner of Parkes have in common with Anas Sarwar, the new Scottish Labour Party leader?

Answer: They were all dentists before going into politics.

Send your trivia to redbox@thetimes.co.uk
 
Follow us
Facebook Twitter Email
This email is from a member of the News UK group. News Corp UK & Ireland Limited, with its registered office at 1 London Bridge Street, London, SE1 9GF, United Kingdom is the holding company for the News UK Group and is registered in England No. 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.

To see our privacy policy, click here.