Problems viewing this? Click to view in your browser
The Times and Sunday Times
with Matt Chorley
Wednesday July 13 2016
Good morning,

They're changing the guard at Buckingham Palace: out goes David Cameron and in comes Theresa May. The papers are full of speculation about who will be in May's first cabinet, but in the first sign of the way her spin operation will work, there is little in the way of actual facts.

There are also lots of comment pieces and leader columns on Cameron's legacy as PM, many of which are rather kinder than he might have expected.

And Jeremy Corbyn clings on. Obviously.
In today’s briefing
  • Labour on course for split
  • Brick thrown at Eagle's office
  • May meets ma'am
  • Amber Rudd for chancellor?
  • Cameron says his goodbyes
  • Brexit could take six years
  • Ruth Davidson on leadership climax
 
Top News
Corbyn's Labour
Corbyn clings on. Obviously
Well that went well.

For the past two and a half weeks, rebel Labour MPs insisted they had a plan. Hilary Benn telling Jeremy Corbyn to go would work. The mass resignation of the shadow cabinet would work. A vote of no confidence by the Parliamentary Labour Party would work. Tom Watson brokering a deal with the unions would work. Finding a unity candidate to trigger a leadership challenge would work.

Anyone with the stamina to look past the more pressing events engulfing the Conservative government in recent days will have noticed that none of it has worked.

And so last night came the crunch moment when a vote was forced in the National Executive Committee to stop Corbyn automatically getting on the ballot paper in a new leadership contest. And that didn't work either.

During a highly charged meeting - during which at one point Corbyn refused to leave the room - Labour’s governing body chose by 18 members to 14 to guarantee that he could take part in a leadership election without the need for 51 nominations from MPs and MEPs. The man who won with 60 per cent of the vote just ten months ago is widely expected to win again - and the Labour Party will split.

As Corbyn and his henchman Jon Trickett left the meeting for a victory lap in front of supporters outside, his opponents forced another vote on who will get a say in choosing the leader.

I know it's hard to believe, but they've made it complicated and it is unclear whether it helps or hinders the battle to remove Corbyn.

Only those who have been members of the party for six months can have a say, excluding the 129,000 who have signed up since the EU referendum .

But new members could still vote if they sign up as registered supporters, this time for £25 — higher than the £3 many Corbyn-backers paid in the contest last year. The race is now on to see whether the hard left or the centrists can persuade more of their supporters to part with £25 when applications open for two days from Monday.

Meanwhile Corbyn's opponents still can't decide who to back as a challenger: Angela Eagle, who launched her bid on Monday, or Owen Smith, who will announce his intention to run today.

It is important to remember that if there had been anyone decent to mount a run for the leadership last year, they should have been able to beat Corbyn. There wasn't, and there still isn't.

Labour has had no one of outstanding quality since Tony Blair and Gordon Brown dominated British politics; the latter squashing any rising stars who might prevent his move to No 10. Since then the party has lacked both ideas and personalities able to hold on to either its traditional electoral bases in Scotland, Wales and England's industrial north, or make inroads into Middle England where elections are won and lost.

The party has lost its way, facing challenges from the Conservatives, Ukip and the SNP, with no plan to take on any of them.

The optimists now insist that the creation of a new, centre-left party will work. We'll see.

Brick thrown at MP's office
There is a troubling side to the problems facing the Labour Party: Angela Eagle ordered Jeremy Corbyn yesterday to “get control” of his supporters after a brick was thrown through her constituency office window just hours after she launched a leadership bid.

“This isn’t the kinder or better politics we were promised," Eagle said, mocking her leader.

Cartoon
Today’s cartoon from Peter Brookes
The next PM
Rudd in tooth and claw
There are two sorts of Theresa May: the steady, cautious, low-profile, getting on with the job, don't frighten the horses Theresa May. And the bold, big bang, element of surprise, expect-the-unexpected Theresa May.

Today we find out which Theresa May will walk into No 10 as prime minister and start forming the new cabinet.

The cautious Theresa May would make Philip Hammond chancellor, keep George Osborne on as foreign secretary, make sure Michael Gove and Boris Johnson are happy with plum roles.

The bold Theresa May would make Amber Rudd chancellor, wave goodbye to Osborne and offer Gove and Johnson low-level jobs or no jobs at all. Up to half of the new cabinet would be women, with Karen Bradley and Justine Greening first in line.

Of course, she'll have to balance Brexiteers and Remainers, experience against new talent. But there are a lot of people in the Tory party who hope it is bold Theresa May who crosses the threshold in Downing Street tonight.

The new PM might not shout about it, but has worked steadily behind the scenes to mentor women into becoming candidates, then MPs then ministers. Now she has a chance to shape the government, and will never have as much power in a reshuffle as she does today.

Rudd, who was the "aristocracy co-ordinator" for the film Four Weddings and Funeral, only became an MP six years ago, and played a high-profile role in the Remain campaign before throwing her weight behind May's bid for the leadership. She will be rewarded with one of the great offices of state: chancellor, foreign secretary or home secretary.

We'll find out which one in a few hours.

 
Comment
Now is not the time for May to gamble with the economy
Theresa May has attempted to define an animating mission for her government beyond Brexit; yet Brexit will undoubtedly define her premiership. No matter the narrative, the first priority is clearly negotiating the best possible deal for Britain with our European partners. May will need to answer two major questions before crafting her negotiating strategy. First, what migration policy is desirable? Second, if aspects of access to the single market are the price, which parts should we be willing to give up? Read the full article on the Red Box website
 
The next PM
May meets ma'am
Before Theresa May can start shaping the government, there is the small matter of saying goodbye to her predecessor.

David Cameron tells the Telegraph that he leaves Britain a "stronger country" with a "thriving economy and more chances to get on in life".

Several papers report that he has drawn up a resignation honours list, with the spin doctor Craig Oliver, fixer Gabby Bertin, chief of staff Ed Llewellyn and aide Liz Sugg in line for gongs.

This morning he will gather his closest advisers to prepare for his final prime minister's questions. The weekly meeting, usually dominated by laughter as jokes are crafted for use at the despatch box, will be a more sombre affair.

When his final half-hour session in the Commons comes to an end, senior Tories will start a round of applause. It will be interesting to see if Jeremy Corbyn, Labour and the SNP join in.

Then it will be back to No 10 for a final time, to gather his thoughts and his family, before addressing the cameras and heading to Buckingham Palace to see the Queen.

Shortly afterwards, May will travel to the palace for her first royal audience, before returning to Downing Street to deliver her first speech as PM. The British constitution fulfilled with ruthless efficiency.

Stewart Wood, who worked for Gordon Brown in No 10, has written a nice piece on the day of goodbyes when a prime minister moves out, including Cameron waking to the realisation that "he will no longer be at the centre of things – a thought that will fill him with a mixture of emptiness and delight".
New backbencher means the party's off
David Cameron vowed yesterday to be an obedient backbencher as he chaired an emotional final cabinet meeting before leaving office.

He will swap his study at the heart of No 10 for a large office in parliament, to the irritation of Welsh Tory MPs told to move out to make space. I understand he will base himself in an office in a prime spot in the main parliament building.

The room, dubbed the “Welsh Tower”, is being vacated by a group of Tory MPs from Wales. It was due to be used by researchers next week for an end of term party, known to be one of the more raucous on the parliamentary estate. Cameron’s arrival has forced it to be cancelled.

Must Read
I have always liked the lust for life and sense of humour the professionalism shields from view. It must be something of a consolation that some of the things he likes most — shooting, drinking fine wine with friends, very good food, jumping into cold water, the occasional cigar, bad jokes — can be indulged less furtively in future.
Brexit Britain
Brexit could take six years, says Hammond
The strange thing about the referendum vote on June 23 is that people now talk as if "Brexit" is in the past. We have "left" the European Union.

In fact, not only have we not walked through the exit, we don't even know where the door is yet. Philip Hammond, who at the time of writing is foreign secretary, has warned it could take six years to disentangle Britain from the EU: two years to negotiate and a further four years to fully ratify.

Meanwhile Angela Merkel has said she wants a business-as-usual approach to trade with the UK after Brexit, keeping the impact on the other 27 countries "as small as possible". Read the story
 
Comment
From Rolls Royce to Handcart? The future of Whitehall in a Brexit world
The UK civil service has traditionally been likened to a Rolls-Royce when it came to matters European. However dysfunctional political attitudes of the UK towards the EU have been, the civil service machinery supposedly purred away, ensuring effective organisation and influence at the technical level. What, then, is the future of this Rolls-Royce in a world outside EU membership?
Read the full article on the Red Box website
 
SW1
Nothing but the Ruth
Ruth Davidson came to parliament yesterday promising jokes, and she didn't disappoint. I've pulled together the Scottish Tory leader's best lines on the Red Box website, but your day is not complete if you haven't seen her unique explanation of the recent leadership turmoil:

"Labour is still fumbling with its flies while the Tories are enjoying their post-coital cigarette… after withdrawing our massive Johnson. Sorry that’s not even my speech, that’s just a text from Stephen Crabb."

She then added a terrific swipe at Andrea Leadsom: “I didn’t say that. You can’t report that. And it would be gutter journalism of the highest order if you have written down exactly what I just said.”

 
The Sketch
Rib-tickler Ruth is the tonic to Theresa’s ice
The difference between the Palace of Westminster and the Scottish parliament, as Ruth Davidson explained after lunch in the former yesterday, is stark. “Holyrood doesn’t have scaffolding up and the toilets work,” she said. “There’s enough space and electronic voting means we’re not stuck there until 3am going through the lobbies.” Read the full sketch
 
 
Red Box Podcast

Rachel Sylvester joins Matt Chorley to give the inside story on THAT interview with Andrea Leadsom, plus Matthew Parris and Lucy Fisher on what sort of PM Theresa May will make and whether David Cameron should be remembered for more than Brexit. Right arrow
 
Briefs
SANDERS BACKS CLINTON After a year of ideological conflict Hillary Clinton was finally endorsed yesterday by Bernie Sanders in a show of unity that many Democrats feared might never happen. Read the story
DISABILITY HATE CRIME Hate crime against disabled people has risen by more than 40 per cent in a year, including assaults and verbal abuse. Read the story
UKIP LEADERSHIP RULES Anger has erupted in Ukip over new rules for its leadership contest that will block well-known figures from standing. Read the story
WHITEHALL LURES OUTSIDERS All civil service posts are to be advertised externally as part of a drive to bring highly paid commercial experts into Whitehall.
Read the story
TUTOR ABUSE WARNING Parents have been urged to carry out checks before hiring private tutors after a charity gave warning that tutoring could provide cover for child abusers. Read the story
DAIRY FARM CLOSURES One in ten dairy farms in England and Wales has closed in the past three years. The Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board warned that the low prices paid to farmers for milk was driving them out of business.
Read the story
 
TMS
From the diary

Two slender volumes
There are now two biographies of Mrs May being bashed out to cash in on the public demand. The Biteback one, which the diary mentioned yesterday, will be by Rosa Prince, who wrote a biography of Jeremy Corbyn this year. It will be beaten into print by John Blake Publishing, which hopes to get a version by Virginia Blackburn out by September 1. Lucky that the new PM is renowned for being such a rich source of entertaining anecdotes...
 
Top 5
Wednesday's best comment

1. May will inherit Cameron’s poisoned chalice
- Daniel Finkelstein, The Times

2. The rich must beware the new puritanism
- Alice Thomson, The Times

3. My motto: beware Greeks bearing kids
- Matthew Parris, The Times

4. He achieved much. But if he'd been driven by more conviction, Dave could have been a great PM
- Quentin Letts, Daily Mail

5. Theresa May is no liberal – and her rise to PM is no cause for celebration
- Aida Edemariam, The Guardian
What The Papers Said

The Times
"There has never been a political leader in British history with either a larger mandate or a smaller mandate than Jeremy Corbyn. Ten months ago more than a quarter of a million Labour Party members elected him to be their leader. In recent weeks 80 per cent of his parliamentary party has declared that it has no confidence in him." Read more

The Guardian
"History will remember David Cameron for the one huge failure of Brexit, the greatest foreign policy reverse since Suez; and perhaps, when the dust has finally settled over this catastrophe, for the many smaller retreats. He morphed from a politician of promise, with an appeal that went beyond traditional Tories, to a prime minister of broken promises who finally betrayed even the best interests of his country." Read more

Daily Mail
"Mr Cameron’s achievements far outweigh his disappointments. He is an engaging and thoroughly decent politician who always looked and sounded like a leader, representing Britain at home and abroad with confidence and poise. He came to power in truly precarious times and has left the nation immeasurably stronger than he found it. That is his legacy to Theresa May." Read more

The Sun
"Free from the EU, May’s Britain must be seen by the world as open for business and a magnet for investment. That will mean a smaller state and lower taxes for businesses and workers.It is a huge task, not helped by a small majority and little money to play with. But if Mrs May proves equal to it she will go down as one of the greats." Read more
Agenda
Today
  • David Cameron resigns as prime minister in an audience with the Queen. Theresa May to be appointed his successor.
  • China-EU summit continues in Beijing, with Donald Tusk and Jean-Claude Juncker expected to give a press conference.
  • Government proposals for social work have "significant weaknesses" and social work is "under severe stress", according to a report published by the education committee.
  • Liz Truss, the environment secretary, attends Great Yorkshire Show.
  • 9.30am: Jo Johnson, the science minister, and others give evidence to the science and technology committee on the implications of Brexit for research.
  • 10.00am: Michael Gove, the justice secretary, gives evidence to members of the justice committee on radicalisation in prisons.
  • 2.00pm: MPs on the Treasury committee take evidence on the UK's future economic relationship with Europe.
  • 4.00pm: Ed Vaizey, the culture minister, joins his French counterpart to launch the Franco-British Data Task Force.
  • 6.00pm: Caroline Lucas, the Green MP, chairs public meeting on Trident nuclear weapons system.
House of Commons
  • 11.30am: Wales questions
  • 12.00pm: Prime minister's question time
  • Ten-minute rule motion on the NHS
  • Motion to approve a statutory instrument relating to terrorism
  • General debate on the report of the Iraq inquiry
  • Adjournment on Tay cities deal
House of Lords
  • 3.00pm: Oral questions on universal credit tenants in arrears, Welsh government recycling rates, leak of telegrams from UK embassy in Ankara, and violence in South Sudan.
  • Legislation: Investigatory Powers Bill - committee stage day 2
  • Debate on government assessment of the UK's at sea nuclear deterrant
 
 
Get in touch
Twitter Follow us at @timesredbox

Facebook Like us at facebook.com/timesredbox

Email Email us at redbox@thetimes.co.uk